As you have read more about Paul Farmer’s travels, what do you think are the biggest strengths he and his team bring to their work? What are their biggest challenges?
Permanent link to this article: https://www.gillianhayes.com/US10F12/rr6-dokte-paul-travels/
30 comments
Skip to comment form ↓
Kristy
November 20, 2012 at 10:36 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think the biggest strengths that Paul Farmer and his team have to offer is their compassion, knowledge, and willingness to dedicate their lives to helping other people. Paul Farmer struggled to sleep at night when thinking about the Haitian people suffering from illnesses in need of his help. The fact that he and his team took in patients without any charge is truly an act of compassion. They figure that they obtain much knowledge about health and might as well put it to good use. I did notice that Paul Farmer and his team had the challenge of providing a sufficient supply of resources or finding enough help at times. For example, during the short time span Paul Farmer headed back home, there was a Haitian patient who came in looking help but there was none to be found. As a result, she passed away. Paul Farmer was notified that he would have been able to easily save her life if he had been there.
Linda Huynh
November 15, 2012 at 11:56 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Farmer’s dedication to his work and patients’ is incredible. His mindset that providing healthcare to the community goes beyond prescribing medication. He believes that it a doctor’s fault if a treatment is not completed or fully effective. His strength shown through his commitment to a patient was illustrated when he hiked three hours up hills to see a patient who had not turned up to an appointment. He goes beyond conventional roles as a health provider and connects to his Haitian community more personally. On a more intimate level, he never rushes through his patients regardless of a packed waiting room and is attentive to each individual. A strength more than his connect to the Haitian people is his love for medicine practice. Farmer is an intellectual individual who is using his skills to assist those who need it most.
Farmer and his team face challenges including the state in which Haiti remains impoverished. Famine affects majority and disease consumes the citizen. TB and HIV are two illnesses that Farmer faced and although treatments are available, the price and sacrifice is tremendous. Lack of resources is a challenge for Farmer’s facility. Generous grants and donations keep his medical practice in Haiti running, but the people require more than a diagnosis and treatment. They need nutritional supplements and transportation expenses for future appointments. A trained medical staff is also lacking, illustrated in an occasion when interns administered antibiotics without doing a spinal tap causing great pain to the patient. Or another example, while Farmer was back in the states due to a leg injury, a patient had died of TB, and his staff said that the patient could have been saved if he had been there. A potential challenge could be the popular belief in sorcery among the Haitian people. This conflicts with the orders of science and medicine. Patients would not understand the idea of TB and bacteria and would stop medication because they believed the curse had been lifted when in actuality, the bacteria remained. A difference in belief could jeopardize an entire treatment plan and this was something Farmer and his team faced.
Ellen Lee
November 15, 2012 at 3:38 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think Paul Farmer’s biggest strength him and his team has is passion and perseverance. It takes a great deal of it to enter a community abroad like of Haiti and perform the work he does. I think passion in general, more than anything, is incredibly powerful and serves as the driving force behind a person’s decisions and actions, and for Paul Farmer, it is his passion to aid others, and establish for them a culture of health equality. Given the amount of difficulties he and his team has faced, they manage to persevere and move on because their ultimate goal is larger than that of any obstacles they can encounter.
Many of the challenges him and his team faces are due to financial reasons. Without sufficient funds, it is becomes difficult for him and his team to carry out their mission. With a shortage in funding, they will lack in resources, which him and his team will have to make up for with their time and effort. Despite his efforts to train others to carry out the tasks he does, it always seem as though what he is doing is a one man job, where the entire country is relying on the assistance of this one man, and I think its incredible. Unlike other larger organizations who have multitude of resources, Paul Farmer’s resources are often times limited, yet his accomplishments are massive.
Jay Bills
November 15, 2012 at 1:58 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think his greatest strengths are his polarized views of social justice mixed with his personal sense of duty and responsibility. He believes that everyone, without regard to financial situation, deserves access to “good” medical treatment. He also believes that it is his responsibility to do what he is can to better the lives of others. I think the biggest challenges that he and his team face are apathy and the public’s lack of awareness. People in our wealthy societies are happy to continue living ignorantly, unaware of the problems of our fellow human beings. So, why should we invest out resources to solve “their” problems. I don’t know how to fix this, but I think he is courageous for trying.
Arshdeep Gill
November 15, 2012 at 1:56 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Dr. Farmer and his team have many strengths that help them in working with their patients, but at the same time they do also face challenges such as a lack of resources to accommodate all their patients. The biggest strength that Dr. Farmer has is commitment and love for what he does. Dr. Farmer passionately loves helping other people, even if that means he himself is at ill health. Farmer never turns away a patient, and when resources are not enough he always finds a way to work around by working harder. Besides Dr. Farmer’s passion for his job, his ability to integrate himself into the Haitian community tremendously helps him connect to the people. Dr. Farmer puts himself into the culture of the Haitian people, in many ways like an anthropologist would. He shows respect for the people’s beliefs and curiosity to learn more about their culture. This deep connection between Dr. Farmer and the Haitian people make Farmer’s job much easier.
Some challenges that Dr. Farmer and his team face are a lack of resources to accommodate all their patients. With the many patients that Dr. Farmer and his team have to treat on a limited amount of resources, at times it gets difficult for them to help everyone; however Dr. Farmer always finds a way around it by giving up some of his resources such as time. If Farmer and his team could get more donors they would also be able to get more advanced technology to help people, which would make it much easier and faster to help people. Another challenge that Dr. Farmer and his team face is that many of his patients believe that illnesses are caused by curses by others members of their community. However Dr. Farmer respects the people’s beliefs and continues to treat them. Even though Dr. Farmer faces challenges like this, he always goes the extra mile to help his patients, his willingness and passion for what he does is what makes him such a good doctor and role model.
Francis
November 15, 2012 at 1:53 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think that Dr. Farmer’s biggest strength is his commitment to the work he is doing. All of the work that he takes on and does is purposeful and he pursues it with his vision and determination to, not only bring it to fruition, but to do more. He and his team utilize their vision to expand to other areas. Their strong sense of purpose is what enables them to be so receptive and effective. They keep their patients in mind and always search for ways to assist a patient. When Farmer first saw the lady who had died by the mangoes, he stayed silent and I think it is his deep pensiveness that allows him to see the problems in front of him and look for ways to confront and ameliorate them. Their team is so strong because of their dedication to the people and communities they serve and also to their practice. Their sense of purpose also helps them overcome the obstacles faced in societies where disparity is so prevalent and is the economic condition of the country. Particularly in the case of the woman by the mangoes, the officer told the public that she was dead without any signs of concern.
Amanda Iaali
November 15, 2012 at 1:34 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Success comes about in a lot of different ways. Actually, depending on what you define success as, it can come about in any way. I believe that Paul Farmer’s definition of success revolves around bringing health care into the Haitian communities he considers his home. I also believe that many of his and his team’s characteristics helps this success come about. His way of being compassionate, and consistent, and persistent has allowed for many successes. His challenges have prevented a lot of those successes too. Because his idea of success includes health care, challenges involve lack of resources and spread of knowledge. There is not enough money, or medicine, or advocacy for his cause. However, I think their strengths help to counter the challenges (moreso than the challenges counter their strengths). Compassion allows for their interactions with patients to be sincere and caring beyond the shallow sense of the word. Consistency builds trust that spreads a hope throughout Cange. And persistence provides a standing ground on which the team stands and won’t back down upon. This allows them to find pathways to success, despite the challenges in their way. An additional challenge may be a lowering of hope in themselves, as more and more challenges are brought about. But I believe their compassionate and consistent persistence helps to alleviate any discouragement their line of work inevitably offers.
Irasema Bueno
November 15, 2012 at 1:34 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think that his biggest strength would definitely have to be his determination to help people. He does what he thinks is the right thing to do and never turns anyone away, he manages to make connections that later on help him. His biggest challenges would have to be the lack of funding that he gets and the lack of knowledge that the people of Haiti have in dealing with diseases. This is a challenge because they are not quick to accept his help and think that something else is causing their illness.
Christina Ong
November 15, 2012 at 1:33 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Through the reading, I believe that Dr. Paul’s biggest strength is the deep compassion and care he has for his patients, regardless of their race, gender, or socioeconomic status. He is selfless and passionate about the people of Haiti. I think that a lot of people who go to developing nations to do service there always regard the people they serve as lesser than them. However, Dr. Paul takes the time and understanding to truly serve these people and give them better lives through healthcare.
I think that a challenge Dr. Paul and his team face are gaining donors and financial sponsorships. Though Dr. Paul is dedicated and extremely intelligent, he requires much money to keep his clinic running and advancing equipment. I think it’s important for Dr. Paul to teach others about the healthcare plight in Haiti in order to gain donors.
Gabriela Manzo
November 15, 2012 at 1:31 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I found it difficult to single out one of Paul Farmer’s strengths. He is incredibly dedicated to his role as a doctor and a humanitarian. He feels responsible for distributing his wealth of knowledge as a practitioner if he knows how to cure those vulnerable, less privileged ones. He also courageous in going into these areas risking his own health and that of his time for the good of others. They are risking their health and safety. He uses a lot of practical intelligence and ingenuity to solve problems that arise. In sum, Farmer and his team are very good-hearted individuals who are sacrificing their own time, safety, and health to treat others.
The biggest challenge Farmer and his team faces in the lack of money they have to meet the demands of their jobs. They often find themselves running out and being faced with the notion of having to use their own to meet the demands of their tasks. The lack of money makes it that more challenging to treat those who seriously ill as well as those who are ill due to unsanitary or unhealthy living conditions. Sometimes when it comes to helping those individuals with preventive measures such that as building better home infrastructure it becomes difficult to fund.
Sam Shaw
November 15, 2012 at 1:27 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Paul Farmer and his team are truly an inspiration. To me, the most obvious strength amongst them is their persistence. One of my favorite quotes is short yet too the point “Actions express priorities”. This quote exemplifies the work of Farmer and his team. They push through all financial, social and personal hardships to focus on their goal. Farmer sacrifices for the well-being of these underprivileged individual in Haiti. His fight for TB within these affected communities pervade through all difficulties. Dr Farmer could not just sit around and hope someone would make a positive change; he had to be proactive in his work. For example, his relationship with Tom White -a major donor for Partners in Health-catalyzed the possibility for cure within Haiti. We can see through Dr Farmer’s actions that his priority was the well-being of these affected individuals. He had a burning fire inside that had one goal to help. This is something we can all aspire to become: persistent.
The biggest challenge, for obvious it may seem, is the financial aspect. To fund medical care, living costs and travel expenses, is not an easy task. Farmer saw dilapidated homes, impoverished communities and sick people all combined to be a huge task for one person with a small team. But it did not stop them. It will require hundreds of thousands of dollars to realistically support Farmer’s passion. I know personally I have had a difficulty with that. For example, I aspire to fund a friend from central Bangkok to the United States so she can experience travel, American culture, and positive relationships. Unfortunately it is not as easy as I expected. It requires the cost of airfare, food, living expenses, health insurance etc….So seeing how Farmer made his medicinal aspiration come alive shows how even our biggest challenges can come alive.
Crystal Polard
November 15, 2012 at 1:23 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think Farmer’s biggest challenges is not taking care of himself. For example, he doesn’t feel when he gives his Chicago speech. Instead of fighting off the sickness when it first kicks in, he ignores his body and keeps on going on no matter how busy he gets. This leads to his diagnosis with Hepatitis A. I think he like forgets about his own health because he’s so dedicated to his work. For instance, you might get carried away and forget to have time for yourself when you love your job or what you do. His greatest strengths is giving everything his all when it comes to helping patients and not being arrogant like Farmer doesn’t think he is above his medical team and that’s really humble and good. I liked it when he said “We are ready to help you in anyway that we can” (157). This shows that he cares about his patients a lot and thinks that helping is a privilege so he takes delight in helping others. However, another challenge is money because Farmer and his team had to borrow their drugs because they were too expensive to buy and takes risks to help save and cure others. I admire that looking beyond yourself attitude. Even though Haiti is in poverty. he helps anyway and persists taking on the never give up attitude.
Amanda Jimenez
November 15, 2012 at 1:23 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Throughout Dr. Farmers’ travels motivation for civic and community engagement is what drives the team to continue on. Some of the team’s biggest strengths include knowledge, passion, and commitment. Farmers’ small group traveled to risky areas to provide medical attention to those who would never get it otherwise. Education is a privilege and those who have been granted it should utilize it for the greater good. Anyone can have passion but when your passion is to help others and you have to privilege of education you have to power to do so much. With committed individuals that have the same passion you do you can accomplish so much. Dr. Farmer and his team have all these qualities and push forward for public health in developing.
There are big challenges that come with having big dreams. Wanting to help communities at the level at which Farmer and his team is requires a lot of financial support and that challenge will continue to be present during their journey. Access to the type of medical equipment and supplies for large communities will also be a continuing challenge because of the areas the team travels to. Farmer is confident that with the strong qualities already existing in his team money is not a big issue because somehow they will get it.
Brian Austin
November 15, 2012 at 1:10 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The biggest strength that Paul Farmer and his team bring to their work is the ambition to solve any problem they face regardless of any difficulty or criticism they may face for their methods. Farmer and his team at PIH have the simple goal of treating the patients no matter what the cost may be. For example, as PIH worked to cure patients of MDR, critics argued that it could not be done in poor countries such as Peru due to the high cost and low treatment success rate, yet Farmer and his team ignored those claims and eventually reached an 85% success rate in the Peru clinic. As a premedical student, I find this philosophy of patient care to be admirable, as it keeps medical care a human process, rather than a simple computation of statistics.
One of the major challenged that Farmer and his team face was the criticism that many public health experts showed toward the ideas to cure MDR. This story highlights a difficult problem in public health, which is the choice between cost-effectiveness or saving a few patients lives, yet Farmer and PIH break down the problem in very simple terms. For the case of MDR, they presented the simple option of either treating the problem now, or face a more expensive and serious problem in the future. This allowed them to gain the support to continue with their work and succeed in curing many patients with MDR.
Maggie Wu
November 15, 2012 at 1:09 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Dr. Farmer contains genuine compassion and passion for his work. One thing I truly admire about him is his ability to stay focused on his goal and his passion. He truly knows where his heart lies and he dedicates his time into pursuing more knowledge through helping others. I believe this is the epitome of becoming engaged because in helping others and becoming more aware, he was able to learn more about the culture and himself. These qualities are all which make a great doctor, and it is truly inspirational. The biggest strength that I have seen in the team is their ability to compromise, because they are all willingly to sacrifice time or effort in the name of helping others. However, even the most passionate team will come across challenges. A few challenges I see that are prevalent in the novel include money and working through cultural differences. It’s extremely difficult. especially if foreigners are telling natives what to do. Money, as always, remains a problem in every practice. In order to help others a great deal of funds need to be raised, and this is a continuing challenge that Dr. Farmer’s team must face.
Dennis Nguyen
November 15, 2012 at 11:37 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I would say one of the biggest strength Dr. Farmer exhibits is his love and understanding. He truly wants to help the less fortunate people of Haiti and loves what he does. He goes out of his way to really give the people what they need. He doesn’t just focus on the big things but also the little things that we take for granted. He found a blind person glasses to wear and gave another nail clippers. Small gestures like these show that the doctor really loves the people he works with. Also he is understanding. The people call him a god or that he is a voodoo priest. He doesn’t shoot them down or berate them. Instead he understands where their belief system comes from and rolls with it. A challenge he faces is a financial one. The world revolves around money and medicine is no different. He needs donors in order to get the more expensive medicine to the Haitians.
Yasufumi Mizuno
November 15, 2012 at 9:09 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The biggest strength he and his team is sharing strong belief. They believe people who suffer MDR should be treated even though it’s very expensive and they don’t have money to pay. Thanks to the belief, they could handle many difficulties.
Their biggest challenge is money. Main tools for cure have to be imported in poor countries they work. The cost per person is very expensive. One especially difficult case costs $250,000. And in average, it costs $1000-2000. In order to get money from big donors, they have to pass cost-effective analysis. They achieved that by reducing dramatically medicine cost. They reduced about 90% by showing a lot of TB projects using the drags. It affects the way to treat TB all over the world. Because they believe what they do is right, they can do things that seem to be impossible. Their passion for cure of patients made them do such a wonderful job.
Austin McKofka
November 15, 2012 at 5:25 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The more I read about Paul Farmer and his team the more I see their strengths, as well as the challenges the face. Farmer himself is a great listener and very intelligent. Farmer and his team are very willing to immerse their entire self into their work. The strengths that he and his team hold vary. Farmer is self-sacrificing and this is reflected in his team dynamic, “…If I took steps to be a doctor for those who don’t have medical care, it could be regarded as a sacrifice…I fell ambivalent about selling my services in a world where some can’t buy them” (24). Furthermore, Farmer hires and trains Haitians and Peruvians to be able to serve their own community as health workers, which gives the clinics a more intimate feel as well as a sense of self-autonomy and culture. This allows these countries to help themselves when the “white man is not around”.
A challenge that him and his team face is finding money to fund the clinics and buy a sufficient amount of medicine, the kind that is not out of date. They also need money to get diagnostic tools that are improved and current. However Farmer remains optimistic, “Of course we’ll find the money” (30). Another challenge Farmer and his team face is the conflict of sorcery and medicine, how some patients do not take medication because they don’t believe that biology is the cause, but rather an outside force, a curse sent by their enemy. Language barriers for more global clinic locations also become a problem as Farmer cannot speak Spanish. Despite the various challenges, Farmer’s vast compassion and keen intelligence rubs off on those around him and creates an environment of optimism and belief in success.
Michelle Huang
November 15, 2012 at 1:00 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The biggest strength Farmer brings to his work is the ability to understand Haitian culture and their religion. Instead of calling the Haitians out for believing in something that has no scientific basis, he sympathized with them. In this way, he can relate to his patients more. He and his team are also very persistent in helping the Haitians and Carabayllonas. The TB treatments were expensive but they still managed to get the money to for them. Farmer also wrote a lot of articles about the conditions in those countries, which incited some people who wanted to help. Jim was able to lower the prices of drugs for MDR, which made treating the disease much more cost-effective.
I think the biggest challenge they faced was convincing the Peruvian government that they should treat MDR patients. Reading about how the authorities did not want to admit that their TB program had a flaw was frustrating. So many people were dying from this disease, but they thought it was too expensive to treat; that it would die out from Dots treatment; and it was less contagious than regular TB. All of these were myths that they believed. Fortunately, Farmer’s team were eventually able to treat and cure patients with the disease. After so much adversity, I am glad that they were able to accomplish such an amazing feat.
Angeli Phan
November 15, 2012 at 12:52 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
As I have learned more about Paul Farmer’s travel and the progress he brings to underprivileged communities, some of his biggest challenges he faces are finance in addition to the mortality he is submerged in everyday. Because of the highly expensive treatment for MDR Tuberculosis, it is difficult accommodate patients who have built immunity to over five different types of preventative treatments for tuberculosis. Currently, there are about fifty patients who are receiving the MDR treatments because it costs nearly $15,000 to $20,000 per patient. Although Farmer has a team of colleagues back in the states willing to help support his cause, there is still insufficient funds provided for the people. The need of treatment for these communities outnumbered the amount of resources and healthcare workers provided to the people
One of the most journeys Farmer endured was father Jack’s death. He was infected with TB and was unable to survive with the treatments because of is extensive resistance to drug medications. Later on in the chapters, Farmer came across a group of ten people that had the MDR similar to Jack. With Farmers strengths in connecting relationships and joining parallel aspects of the patient’s illness, he was able to derive a hypothesis that concludes reasons why people in Carabayllo build strong resistance against treatments. There resistance was created not because of the patient’s improper use of treatment. It was actually the fault of healthcare workers who did not carefully administer proper care and treatment to those who were infected with TB. Since they were reckless prescribing dosages and treatment plans for patients, the TB rapidly mutated into becoming terminal. As their research progresses, more and more problems arise with more drug resistant patients and improperly trained healthcare workers. But their best quality as a team is their optimism and motivation to create outreach programs, and the connections they have with health care workers and colleagues back home.
Patrick M.
November 15, 2012 at 12:48 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The biggest strength Farmer and his team have is their passion for the Haitian people. Farmer in particular was too committed to the poor, leaving little room for others. His immense passion specifically alienated Ophelia Dahl, Pa former love interest whom Farmer wanted to marry. Farmer contracted dysentery and if he became any sicker he would have had to been transported back to the US. Farmer sacrificed his own health in order to stay and travel to other parts of Haiti. Another strength of Farmer and his team is their respect of the Haitian people. This establishes a relationship that benefits Farmer and the Haitians because Farmer teaches and trains the natives to care for themselves, as well as others.
Although Farmer and his team have an immense passion, they still lack monetary funds, resources, and support. You can have all the passion in the world, but it still won’t be able to buy you some of the simple necessities that the people of Haiti need. But although these are problems that Farmer faces, he still finds a way to help these people, like when he wrote back home to his friends and family asking for donations to help the Haitian people.
Emily McVey
November 15, 2012 at 12:29 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
The biggest strengths of Farmer and his team are their forward looking attitude and their general consensus to think that anything is possible. They hit a lot of obstacles with politics and money, which are probably their biggest challenges, but they find ways to overcome them. When most people are running out of money they get upset and don’t know what to do. Farmer and his team find a way to get money in whatever way they can. They come up with ways to navigate political issues, like dealing with WHO on getting second-line drugs on their lists for medications. They just care about what they are doing and have this really definitive line of right and wrong which guides them through decisions and actions. If they didn’t have that firm line, they could have been swayed by politicians or people telling them they shouldn’t be doing it the way they want. With the firm line, they are able to stick up for what they believe in and continue fighting for each patient.
Nancy Lu
November 15, 2012 at 12:24 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think the biggest strength Paul Farmer and his team brings to their work is their understanding and dedication to this world. Farmer understands how these people are dealing with their living environment because he has gone through it as a child. His medical background and love for medicine allows him to reach out and provide assistance to those that live in these dangerous environments. His dedication to spend all his time in a poor country shows that he is a kind man with a good heart, who has a huge commitment in helping others live a better life.
One of the challenges that Farmer faces is the lack of financial assistance. During one trip to Haiti, he noticed the “roofs of these tiny hovels, roofs made of banana bark thatch, patched with rags, clearly leaky (77).” Because of the difficult living situations, he expected that a majority of them were ill, and that there was no medicine provided there. It is always hard to find funding for a small country because many of the resources are being used in America. It seems that money is always an issue when it comes to providing aid to another world, especially healthcare. For example, when an TB outbreak occurred, it was realized that ” various American agencies had spent about a billion dollars stanching the outbreak, and other countries are in debt when it came to owning back the Americans (141).” This prime example shows how even though Farmer wants to give it his all to providing the help that these people need, money is something that will always set him back.
Annie Lao
November 14, 2012 at 6:14 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think the biggest strengths that Paul Framer and his team have are their dedication, concern, and willingness to help others. They also have a deep understanding of the people they are helping. I also think that in order to have such a persistent and well organized team, they must communicate efficiently and trust one another. Another big strength they have is also education. Education itself is valuable, but when spread and applied, it truly reflects the purpose of education. Framer does this by applying his medical knowledge to help/teach people who are less fortunate. I also think humbleness is a big factor in their success. Their “I’m here to genuinely help” and not “I’m your savior” type of attitude really makes a huge difference. People are usually more accepting of your help, if they do not feel belittled.
I think their biggest challenges are a lack of funding, different cultures/customs, and lack of time. Funding is usually always the biggest challenge in any case. Money makes the world go round, and if a mission is hindered by a lack of money, there is only so much they can accomplish. As for difference cultures/customs as a hardship, one usually has to gain a tribe/group’s trust first. That can take many days or even weeks. Once the trust has been accomplished, the next step would be learning about their lifestyle, traditions, and beliefs. All this is very time consuming and if they do not trust you, there is nothing else you can really do. The last challenge could be a lack of time due to the lack of technology and convenience in rural countries. I feel like we are too relient on cell phones, computers, and cars to take into consideration that some developing countries don’t have the privileges that we have. Farmer and his team would have to rely on walking long distances to treat their patients if they are living in remote areas and if there is a problem that needs solving, Framer and his team can’t simply look up answers on Google. Information is usually passed down by word of mouth and because many people are illiterate and that is not always reliable. While there are many challenges that Framer and his team have to face, I believe they handle and adapt to their situation very well.
Keith Kittirungruang
November 14, 2012 at 10:11 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I think the biggest strengths that Paul and his team bring to their work is their philosophies on how they view the world and their specialties in various areas. Tom White, one of the main donors for Partners in Health was an extremely generous Republican that contributed millions to the organization. He was one who had much experience in helping the poor and has already been giving money away for years. Jim Kim, a student of medicine and anthropology was also another member of Partners in Health. He had a similar mindset as Farmer, that medicine addresses only the symptoms of poverty. In order for there to be change, there must be something done with the “political economies.” Ophelia was Paul’s previous lover. After going through thick and thin with him, they finally became friends. She took on the finances and began scheming about creating an endowment. Yearly, she contributed about three times her salary ($15,000) to the organization. Through action and support, this small team in the Partners in Health organization are able to make a difference in Haiti.
A huge challenge they come across are the patients’ idea of Western medicine. In their culture, they use Voodoo as an explanation for their sickness. It is often said that another person put a curse on them, making them contract diseases like tuberculosis and AIDS. Farmer explains Voodoo as something to blame, because these patients have never received any help in their lives. They need some sort of excuse for why there is so much suffering. This mentality that a neighbor has put a curse on them could potentially make them not want to take the medicine that is given to them, given that they think it will do nothing for them. It is a challenge for Paul and his team to be able to change the attitude toward Western medicine in such a poverty-stricken area.
Stephanie Olvera
November 13, 2012 at 11:07 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I believe that Farmer’s biggest strength is his perseverance to unconditionally help these people. Even through riots and outbreaks, he disregards the law and forces himself into the countries that he knows need his help. Thanks to Farmer’s power of will, the team gathers hope even when the resources and budget state otherwise. Although often skeptical, Farmer’s group follows through as the doc says. His self-commitment economically stretches out his resources and seeks to inform people about the major problem, the TB. Even with his own medical problems, the doctor does not seem to excuse himself from his duty and that is what defines his personal strengths. The main challenges they face are the lack of medical treatment and that most people are not well informed. Consequently, they are not aware of the precautionary measures they can take in the middle of the prevalent virus.
Emily Sandon
November 12, 2012 at 8:39 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Paul Farmer and his team exhibit courage, enthusiasm, cleverness, and intelligence that keep the fight for TB treatment alive. During the revolt in Haiti, Paul Farmer did not give up trying to get back into Haiti when his name was blacklisted to the country; nor did he fear helping anyone in dangerous areas for medical assistance. When Jim was incorporated into the group during the Peru outbreak, Jim believed that “‘a small group of committed individuals’” could bring about change for the better (Kidder 169). This positive attitude helped the efforts of Farmer and the other Peruvian doctors during the MRD containment in Peru. To help further the treatment along in Peru, Paul and Jim would “sweet talk” workers at the Brigham pharmacy to obtain the medicine needed for the men’s trip to Peru (Kidder 149). Practically playing “Robin Hood” and sneaking drugs over to another country takes a lot of bravery to accomplish. Paul Farmer’s use of bringing awareness to the injustice of health care in Peru during a speech for the organization, “International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease” was a smart use of marking the issue and spreading the word. Ophelia, who had been in charge of the budget ever since contributions were being made to the PIH, created an endowment for the organization that helps Paul Farmer and the organization have a decent amount of money in case of emergencies. All of these qualities have contributed to the success Paul Farmer and his team have brought to the awareness, prevention, and treatment of TB.
The challenges Paul Farmer and his team face were international, genetic, and medical issues about TB prevention and treatment. MDR treatment was declared “largely ineffective, but not on the basis of any substantial trails” by the World Health Organization (Kidder 166). By declaring this ineffectiveness, the WHO brought less hope for the exact cause Paul Farmer and his team was trying to bring awareness to, clearly creating an international setback in TB prevention and treatment efforts. Also, “…experts in international TB control had deemed MDR too expensive to treat” creating another problem for the funding of Farmer and his teams efforts of TB (Kidder 141). Even though “Farmer was a TB expert”, patients in Carabayllo could not be identified with the exact type of TB strain contracted, influencing one of the main problems throughout the story of rapidly changing TB strains of the virus (Kidder 138). One of the main causes of these multiple strains of TB was inadequate care of people with TB (Kidder 142). Therefore the lack of resources and knowledge on TB prevention and treatments influenced the increase outbreaks of TB, equaling more money and time costs for Farmer and his team and his patients.
Danica Hom
November 11, 2012 at 9:28 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
One of the strengths that stuck out to me the most about Farmer and his team were how they focused on really integrating themselves into the Haitian community. Instead of taking the stance of ‘we’re from America and we are going to set up an American-run clinic to help you’, Farmer and his team really focused on training locals from their community to help their fellow Haitians. Some of the largest challenges that Farmer and his team face include the unstable state of Haiti, and the dangers presented to foreigners. In the novel, one of Farmer’s friends gets removed from office as president, which puts his supporters (Farmer included) in danger, or on a blacklist. The fact that Farmer continues to return to demonstrates his determination and perseverance, and really shows the genuine love Farmer has for the Haitians.
Patricia Peirce
November 11, 2012 at 10:36 am (UTC -8) Link to this comment
Dr. Farmer is certainly a personality on his own right. I think his strengths are basically his conscious attitute about what is right and wrong in the world he lives. So, based on that Dr. Farmer utilizes his abilities as a doctor but more than that his humanity translate into an immense body of work helping others. He himself suffers from asthma and high blood pressure but he managed to travel constantly in service to others, not to mentioned a bad left leg. I also think that Dr. Farmer’s overall efforts of helping others are not by any means lessened by the real constrains of lack of resources, facilities, money and competent medical help in the field but these are certainly challenges he faces.
Joseph Rios
November 8, 2012 at 1:41 pm (UTC -8) Link to this comment
I feel that one of Dr. Farmer’s biggest strengths as a doctor and as a human being is his sense of duty for his job. This sense of duty is what compelled him to have the rule of never turning a patient away. This is what leads into his biggest challenge because like every hospital he is going to run into constraints concerning finances. Also, because he is trying to serve a massive amount of people with a minimal amount of money, he ends up usually paying with his time. This is not a big deal to him because his sense of duty kicks in because he can’t sleep knowing that a patient is untreated.